Commercial Aquatic Centres – Energy Efficiency Analysis & Operating savings

Following a request from a well-known Aquatic centre, Sondex were invited to carry out an energy efficiency assessment on possible waste heat recovery & in addition, if we could try & ascertain or explain why their energy bills have noticeably increased, year after year, but confusingly well above the energy price rises indicated on their statements. Sondex visited two (2) Council & YMCA AQC around Melbourne & were amazed at the findings. The aim was to establish a base line cost for the supply of both Gas & Electricity. As suppliers & rates varied from area to area we decided to take an average for these calculations.

A typical AQC plant room consists of heating boilers, pumps, filtration & Chlorination systems, a plate heat exchanger, valves / controls & heaps of pipe work. The first items we considered were where can energy be lost or inefficiently consumed & are they being maintained for optimum operation. We were able to quickly see that the boiler & plant rooms were actually contracted to a regular service regime & that the boilers were serviced & checked regularly, the filters/chlorination systems are maintained amazingly well, (& for a very good reason) however what we did observe was the absence of any attention to the heat exchangers or pumps. The pumps we can understand, as they will either leak or stop if there is a mechanical problem, but the heat exchangers have no cleaning or inspection regime whatsoever & yet that is the single most important piece of equipment tasked with transferring the energy produced in a boiler into the pool water as efficiently as is humanly possible. Any energy that does not get transferred from the “Heat Exchanger” into the pool water, is simply lost & passed out the flue of the boiler. It really is that simple.

It suddenly became apparent that pool operators assumed the boiler contractors would service the heat exchangers but nothing is further from the truth, that’s like a pilot hoping that the radar technician is also checking the brakes, boilers & heat exchangers are very different appliances & require very different servicing attention.

So, back to the wasted energy & the high bills….

The fact is that as the heat exchanger is a complex series of plates carefully designed, pressed & arranged into honeycomb like array that can super efficiently transfer the heat (energy) created by the boiler into the pool water through very thin layers of Titanium plate. Well certainly that’s the design on day one. The problem that follows is that unless you keep these heat transfer plates clean, they slowly & surely foul up & slowly over time silently stop working efficiently. Picture touching a BBQ plate that is hot (yes ouch!!), now put a layer of dirt or mud on it & suddenly you can touch it & no ouch. That’s what happens on the surface of a heat transfer plate. It builds up layers of human fats, dirt & other foreign bodies & it insulates heat from being transferred.

So when this fouling occurs (& yes it happens to 100% of heat exchangers in this service) the boiler sensors see the pool water is not achieving its required temperature & it fires up, the pool pumps start to receive less water flowing through the (blocking) heat exchanger & so they work harder. The boiler still sees no improvement in the pool temp. & so it stays on high fire for longer…. & thus energy is now being wasted every second of every minute of every day, & yes the numbers really do start to add up.

Unfortunately fouling is like emphysema of the heat exchanger, it is slow subtle & ever so deadly to your constant operating costs. Well now, if that sounds scary then read on as the actual numbers tell the real story.

So here is what really happens inside that little box called a heat exchanger

As it begins to foul up to five system components can be effected:

  1. The first, is the heat transfer through the titanium plates of the heat exchanger reduces. (Tech. terms its Watts per square metre of heat transfer)
  2. This has an immediate effect on the boiler run time. It will spend more time on high fire in an attempt to satisfy the pool temperature.
  3. As the fouling continues the HX is blocking & the pressure drop across the heat exchanger increases, this increases the resistance or back pressure on the pump head, in turn increasing the running cost of the pump (more energy used to achieve a flow).
  4. Over time & left unchecked, this effect will eventually occur on both sides of the heat exchanger effecting both pumps and their running costs.
  5. Eventually the desired pool temperature will begin to drop & not recover. The speed at which this occurs depends on many factors such as, is the pool inside or outside, how many people use the pool, is there a wind factor, the ambient temperature, what season you are in & so on

Increased running cost:

When clean, the average run time of the boiler was 20 minutes in the hour. The boiler output was 485 KW (1,746 MJ) at 75% efficiency the boiler input is 2,328 MJ at 0.6615c/MJ.

  • The boiler normal run time is 20 mins per hour during the 4 months of winter = $14,784.00
  • With a partially blocked plate heat exchanger the boiler run time is 40 mins/Hr = $29,568.00
  • In the event the boiler can no longer maintain pool temperature, run time is 100% = $44,351.19
  • If we take the same approach with the pool pumps at a rate of 5c/KWh the results are as follows. The pumps run continuously so all we need to consider is the cost increase caused by the higher pump head.

Once again based on the averages the pool pump increased its power consumption by approximately 1.0 KW per hour. Over the 4-month period this equates to an increased cost of $144.00 for both pumps during the winter period.

Sondex Australia Pty Ltd
11/899 Wellington Road
Rowville Vic 3178
Tel.: +61 3 9755 6789
Fax: +61 3 9755 6898
Sondex New Zealand Ltd
48/13 Tawn Place
Pukete Hamilton
New Zealand 3200
Tel: +64 7 847 4808

Legal Notice.

Please read these Terms and Conditions carefully before using the Site. By using this Site you signify your consent to these Terms and Conditions. If you do not agree to the Terms, please do not use the Site.

The Site is owned and operated by SONDEX A/S, a corporation incorporated under the laws of Denmark, having its principle office in Denmark. SONDEX A/S maintains the Site for your personal entertainment and information. Please feel free to browse the Site. You may download material displayed on the Site for non-commercial, home personal use only, provided you keep intact all copyright, trademark and other proprietary notices. You may not, however, copy, reproduce, republish, upload, post, transmit or distribute in any way the contents of this Site including the text, images, audio and video for public or commercial purposes, without written permission from SONDEX A/S.

Terms and Conditions
1. You should assume that everything you see or read on this Site is protected by copyright unless otherwise stated and may only be used according to these Terms and Condtions. SONDEX A/S does not warrant or represent that your use of materials displayed on this Site will not infringe rights of  third parties not owned by or affiliated with SONDEX A/S. Images are either the property of, or used with permission by, SONDEX A/S. The use of these images by you, or anyone else authorized by you, is prohibited unless specifically permitted by these Terms and Conditions. Any unauthorized use of the images may violate copyright laws, trademark laws, the laws of privacy and publicity, and communications regulations and statutes.

2. SONDEX A/S uses reasonable efforts to include accurate and up-to-date information on the Site. However, SONDEX A/S makes no warranties or representations as to the accuracy of the information. SONDEX A/S assumes no liability or responsibility for any errors or omissions in the contents of this Site.

3. Furthermore, your use of and browsing in this Site is at your risk. Neither SONDEX A/S nor any other party involved in creating, producing or delivering the Site is liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, consequential or punitive damages arising out of your access to, or use of, the Site. Without limiting the foregoing, everything on the Site is provided to you "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR  NON-INFRINGEMENT. Please note that some the jurisdictions may not allow the exclusion of implied warranties, so some of above exclusions may not apply to you. Check your local laws for any restrictions or limitations regarding the exclusion of implied warranties. SONDEX A/S also assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable for any damages to, or viruses that may infect, your computer equipment or other property on account of your access to, use of, or browsing in the Site or your downloading of any materials, data, text, images, video, or audio from the Site.

4. Any communication or material you transmit to the Site by electronic mail or otherwise, including any data, questions, comments, suggestions, or the like is, and will be treated as, non-confidential and non-proprietary. Anything you transmit or post may be used by SONDEX A/S or its affiliates for any purpose, including but not limited to reproduction, disclosure, transmission, publication, broadcast, and posting. Furthermore, SONDEX A/S is free to use any ideas, concepts, know-how, or techniques contained in any communication you send to the Site for any purpose whatsoever, including
but not limited to developing, manufacturing, and marketing products using such information.

5. The trademarks, and logos, displayed on the Site, are trademarks of the SONDEX Group. Nothing contained on the Site should be construed as granting, by implication, estoppel, or otherwise, any license or right to use any trademark displayed on the Site without the written permission of the SONDEX Group or such third party that may own the trademarks displayed on the Site. Regarding use of the trademarks, see Intellectual Property Rights.

6. The SONDEX Group has not reviewed all of the sites linked to the Site and is not responsible for the contents of any off-site pages or any other sites linked to the Site. Your linking to any other off-site pages or other sites is at your own risk.

7. This Site may contain links to other Web sites operated by third parties other than SONDEX. Such links are provided for your convenience only. SONDEX A/S does not control such Web sites and is not responsible for their content. The fact that this Site contains links to other sites does not mean that SONDEX approves of, endorses or recommends those sites, nor does it imply any association with their operators. SONDEX disclaims all warranties, express or implied, as to the accuracy, legality, reliability or validity of any content on any other site and disclaims all responsibility for any loss, injury, claim, liability or damage of any kind resulting from any third party Web sites or content therein directly or indirectly accessed through links in this Site.

8. The SONDEX Group may at any time revise these Terms and Conditions by updating this posting. You are bound by any such revisions and should therefore periodically visit this page to review the current Terms and Conditions to which you are bound.